Sex Offender Restrictions Eased in Miami-Dade County
I frequently get calls and emails from people telling me how difficult it is for them or for a family member to comply with various sex-offender restrictions. Based upon the following article that appeared on January 22, 2010 in the Miami Herald, it appears that legislators in Miami-Dade County, Florida are being told the same thing and that they had the good sense to ease some of the restrictions in that county.
MIAMI-DADE OK's new sex offender law
|
"Miami-Dade County has taken the first steps to help convicted sex offenders find places to live that aren't tucked in alleyways or shacks under overpasses like the Julia Tuttle Causeway.
Commissioners on Thursday passed, 12-0, a sex offender ordinance that repeals more than 24 different sex offender laws enacted by municipalities within county borders. The new law creates one standard that it hopes will balance the need to protect children while still giving housing options to sexual offenders.
The ordinance also creates a new provision that supporters say is a more workable and realistic solution to protecting children: child-safety zones.
Almost all the municipal ordinances tend ``to create zones in which sexual offenders are completely excluded from available housing,'' the ordinance reads.
Under the child-safety zones, sex offenders are prohibited from loitering within 300 feet of where children congregate. In other words, it restricts sex offenders from being near children, but doesn't leave them homeless.
About 35-50 sexual offenders still live under the Causeway, mostly in thin tents and cardboard boxes. Their plight generated national debate over the consequences of strict residency requirements. In most cases, the sex offenders were placed under the bridge upon their release by the state Department of Corrections.
Diaz predicted that every municipality in the state will adopt ordinances similar to that of Miami-Dade's by the end of the year.
``Whether you are in Aventura or in Homestead, it provides efficiency to the state attorney and law enforcement knowing that there's now one law across the county,'' Diaz said.
Unlike the county, which bans sex offenders from living within a certain distance of schools only, other municipalities' laws go further, banning them from living within 2,500 feet or more of daycare centers, parks, playgrounds and a myriad of other places where children congregate.
PUSHED OUT
Civil libertarians have argued that this leaves sex offenders virtually homeless, making dangerous offenders more difficult to monitor and more likely to go underground and continue harming children.
Now, the revised law maintains the 2,500-foot rule residency restriction from schools, but uses the state's 1,000-foot buffer zone for all other places where children gather.
City officials and civil libertarians had mixed reactions to the ordinance.
``I haven't been totally satisfied that the county has the authority to do this,'' said Miami Beach City Attorney Jose Smith, adding that it ``waters down,'' their city's stricter law.
``I'm not sure how other cities are going to handle this, but I'm not sure we're going to challenge it,'' he said.
MISGIVINGS
The American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, meanwhile, said the county ordinance is a step in the right direction, but doesn't go far enough.
``This has been going on for years -- it's too late for half measures. We need a solution that doesn't go halfway,'' said Courtenay Strickland, director of public policy for the ACLU of Florida, which has challenged the county's 2,500-foot rule in court.
Thus far, sex offenders have been governed by three levels of laws: federal, state and local laws -- all of which target where sex offenders live, some of them stricter than others.
Miami Beach's law, for example, prohibits sex offenders from living within 2,500 feet of a school, bus stop, park, playground ``and other places where children can congregate.''
The city of Miami sued Miami-Dade County last year because the county was allowing the offenders to live too close to a barrier island that it considers a park." |
If sex offenders are to have any hope of getting better and not worse upon release from prison, we cannot continue to treat them like animals and give them no place to live and at least attempt to be a proper member of a community.
This is a good article, but the news has changed. A week ago today approximately 20 sex offenders were kicked out of the living spaces that the Homeless Trust and Lutheran Services had secured for them. Many were told to simply go stay in the parking lot of their PO for the weekend.
The residency laws may have been "eased" in Miami-Dade County, but the issue is far from resolved. Florida legislators have decided the solution to ill-conceived and counterproductive residency laws is to increase the statewide laws from 1000 feet to 1750. While it may "ease" restrictions in Miami, it will cause more urban areas to struggle with JTC style camps zcross Florida.
I'm a criminology major and I can tell you what they are doing to these men is not going to help them in any bit. The reason sex offenders recidivate is because they feel shunned by society and that's exactly what Miami-Dade county is doing. They aren't going to make things better for themselves, they are only going to make them worse. Get a warehouse, put some "beds" in it and there ya go. A place to live as well as a place that these sex offenders can be monitored.